The Marineford War in One Piece was a turning point, not just for Luffy and his crew but for the series’ world at large. Among the many characters affected by the tragedy, Monkey D. Garp’s internal struggle stood out as one of the most heartbreaking. A Marine legend and the grandfather of Ace, Garp was forced to choose between his duty to the Marines and his love for his step-grandson. We will delve into Garp’s journey during and after Marineford, exploring his emotional fallout, his relationship with Ace, and the lasting impact of his grandson’s death.
What Did Garp Expect Before Ace’s Execution?
When Ace’s death sentence was declared, Garp likely found himself struggling with an unbearable sense of helplessness. As someone deeply rooted in the Marines, he knew that the World Government would make an example of Ace to prove their authority.
Still, it’s possible Garp clung to a faint hope that Ace could escape his death—perhaps through Luffy’s intervention or some unforeseen event during the war. His behavior on the execution platform revealed a man conflicted to his heart. Though bound by duty, the pain in his eyes spoke many things about his inner trouble. In his heart, Garp likely wished he could intervene, even if it meant betraying the Marines.
Garp’s Role in the War After Ace’s Death
Ace’s death marked a pivotal moment for Garp. Despite his overwhelming grief, he remained on the battlefield, physically restrained by Sengoku to prevent him from attacking Akainu. This restraint symbolized not only his physical inaction but also his emotional paralysis.
Garp’s role in the war changed after Ace’s death. He became a bystander to the chaos, his grief leaving him unable—or unwilling—to fight. His silence in the face of such tragedy reflected a man broken by the weight of his loss, yet bound by the unyielding chains of duty.
The Emotional Confrontation with Dadan
In one of the most powerful post-war scenes, Garp returned to Dawn Island and faced the wrath of Dadan, Ace and Luffy’s surrogate mother. Dadan’s fiery confrontation encapsulated the grief and anger that many fans felt after Ace’s death.
She lashed out at Garp, blaming him for failing to protect Ace. Her words cut deep: “What good is your title as a hero if you couldn’t save him?” Garp, uncharacteristically, did not retaliate. Instead, he silently accepted her anger, understanding that her pain mirrored his own. This moment underscored Garp’s guilt and his acknowledgment of his perceived failure as both a Marine and a grandfather.
Conversations with Ace Before His Death
While One Piece doesn’t show many detailed conversations between Garp and Ace before the war, their relationship hints at unspoken love and regret. It’s possible Garp tried to steer Ace away from piracy in their earlier years, hoping to save him from the fate that awaited all pirates.
During the war, Garp’s brief exchanges with Ace were filled with tension and sadness. Though he couldn’t openly show it, Garp’s eyes reflected his love for Ace, even as he sat on the side of the executioners. These moments revealed the complexity of their bond—a mix of pride, love, and helplessness.
Garp’s Commitment to the Marines vs. His Love for Family
Throughout his life, Garp upheld the values of the Marines with unchanging dedication. However, Marineford forced him to confront the darker side of justice. His loyalty to the Marines clashed violently with his love for Ace and Luffy, two individuals who defied the law he swore to uphold.
This internal conflict was most evident in his reluctance to act during Ace’s execution. Garp’s silence wasn’t a sign of indifference but of a man torn apart by conflicting duties. His struggle highlights one of One Piece’s recurring themes: the cost of loyalty and the gray areas between right and wrong.
Resigning from the Marines: A Turning Point
After the war, Garp stepped down from active duty in the Marines, choosing instead to train new recruits. While he didn’t leave the Marines entirely, his resignation was likely driven by a mix of guilt, grief, and disillusionment.
Garp’s departure from the frontlines symbolized his rejection of the harsh justice that claimed Ace’s life. By focusing on the next generation, he may have sought redemption, hoping to instill values that balance justice with humanity.
The Potential Showdown with Akainu
The possibility of Garp confronting Akainu in the future looms as a tantalizing prospect for One Piece fans. Garp’s restraint during Marineford was an act of duty, but his resentment towards Akainu—who delivered the final blow to Ace—is undeniable.
Currenly,the man might have been captured by the Blackbeard pirates with the help of his former student. But it does not completely wipe out the possiblity of final showdown between the two old guards of the Marines.